Choose container set to minimize waste
Problem: Optimal Container Set Selection
You are tasked with packaging medicine for shipment and must select exactly one container set to fulfill all customer orders. Once a set is chosen, you can only use containers from that specific set.
Each container set provides containers of defined capacities in unlimited quantity. For every customer order, you must adhere to the following rules:
- Use exactly one container from the chosen set.
- Completely fill the container up to the order amount.
- If no container has a capacity exactly equal to the order amount, you must use the smallest container whose capacity is greater than the order amount.
- The difference
capacity - order_amountis defined as waste for that specific order.
If, for any single order, no container in a chosen set is large enough to accommodate the order_amount, then that container set is considered invalid and cannot be used at all.
Your objective is to evaluate all available container sets and identify the one that:
- Can satisfy all customer orders (meaning for every requirement, there is at least one container in the set with capacity ≥ requirement).
- Results in the minimum total waste, where total waste is the sum of wasted units across all orders.
If multiple container sets yield the same minimum total waste, you must return the smallest index among them. If no container set can satisfy all orders, return -1.
Input Format
YouYou will be provided with:
n: An integer representing the number of orders.requirements[n]: An array ofnpositive integers, whererequirements[i]is the required volume for thei-th order.numContainerSets: An integer indicating the total number of distinct container sets.containers[totalNumContainers][2]: A 2D array describing all container sizes across all sets. Each inner arraycontainers[k]contains:containers[k][0]: The set index (an integer from0tonumContainerSets - 1).containers[k][1]: A container capacity (a positive integer) belonging to that set.
Additional Guarantees for containers:
- Rows are grouped by set index in increasing order.
- Within each set, its capacities are listed in non-decreasing order.
Constraints:
You may assume reasonable constraints such as:
1 ≤ n ≤ 10^51 ≤ numContainerSets ≤ 10^51 ≤ totalNumContainers ≤ 10^51 ≤ requirements[i] ≤ 10^91 ≤ containers[k][1] ≤ 10^9
Waste Calculation for a Single Set
For a specific container set s with capacities C_s and an order of size r:
- Let
cbe the smallest capacity inC_ssuch thatc ≥ r. - The waste for this order under set
sisc - r. - If no such
cexists (i.e., all capacities inC_sare< r), then setsis invalid and cannot be used.
The total waste for set s is the sum of wastes over all orders in requirements.
Required Function
Implement the following function:
int chooseContainers(int requirements[n],
int numContainerSets,
int containers[totalNumContainers][2])
Return Value:
- The 0-based index of the container set that yields the minimum total waste while satisfying all requirements. If multiple such sets exist, return the smallest index among them.
- If no container set can satisfy all requirements, return
-1.
Your algorithm must be efficient enough to handle inputs up to 10^5 in size; a naive solution with O(n × totalNumContainers) time complexity or worse will time out.
Example
n = 4
requirements = [4, 6, 6, 7]
numContainerSets = 3
containers = [
[0, 3], [0, 5], [0, 7], // set 0: capacities {3, 5, 7}
[1, 6], [1, 8], [1, 9], // set 1: capacities {6, 8, 9}
[2, 3], [2, 5], [2, 6] // set 2: capacities {3, 5, 6}
]
- Set 0 with capacities
{3, 5, 7}:- Requirement 4 → use capacity 5 → waste = 5 − 4 = 1
- Requirement 6 → use capacity 7 → waste = 7 − 6 = 1
- Requirement 6 → use capacity 7 → waste = 1
- Requirement 7 → use capacity 7 → waste = 0
- Total waste for set 0:
1 + 1 + 1 + 0 = 3.
- Set 1 with capacities
{6, 8, 9}:- Requirement 4 → use capacity 6 → waste = 6 − 4 = 2
- Requirement 6 → use capacity 6 → waste = 0
- Requirement 6 → use capacity 6 → waste = 0
- Requirement 7 → use capacity 8 → waste = 8 − 7 = 1
- Total waste for set 1:
2 + 0 + 0 + 1 = 3.
- Set 2 with capacities
{3, 5, 6}:- Cannot satisfy requirement 7, as its maximum capacity is 6 < 7.
- Therefore, set 2 is invalid.
Both set 0 and set 1 are valid and yield a total waste of 3. As the smallest index is required, the correct answer is 0.
AI interview prep
Core dilemma
The central engineering conflict is efficiently calculating the total waste for a large number of orders across a large number of container sets. A naive approach (iterating all sets, then all orders, then scanning capacities) is too slow. The challenge lies in optimizing the search for the 'smallest container >= requirement' and aggregating waste, especially when both `n` and `numContainerSets` can be up to 10^5, and capacities/requirements up to 10^9.
3 tradeoffs and 3 stress tests locked
Interview prep
Unlock the interviewer X-Ray rubric, tradeoff matrix, stress tests, clarifying questions, and key concepts.
Choose container set to minimize waste
Problem: Optimal Container Set Selection
You are tasked with packaging medicine for shipment and must select exactly one container set to fulfill all customer orders. Once a set is chosen, you can only use containers from that specific set.
Each container set provides containers of defined capacities in unlimited quantity. For every customer order, you must adhere to the following rules:
- Use exactly one container from the chosen set.
- Completely fill the container up to the order amount.
- If no container has a capacity exactly equal to the order amount, you must use the smallest container whose capacity is greater than the order amount.
- The difference
capacity - order_amountis defined as waste for that specific order.
If, for any single order, no container in a chosen set is large enough to accommodate the order_amount, then that container set is considered invalid and cannot be used at all.
Your objective is to evaluate all available container sets and identify the one that:
- Can satisfy all customer orders (meaning for every requirement, there is at least one container in the set with capacity ≥ requirement).
- Results in the minimum total waste, where total waste is the sum of wasted units across all orders.
If multiple container sets yield the same minimum total waste, you must return the smallest index among them. If no container set can satisfy all orders, return -1.
Input Format
YouYou will be provided with:
n: An integer representing the number of orders.requirements[n]: An array ofnpositive integers, whererequirements[i]is the required volume for thei-th order.numContainerSets: An integer indicating the total number of distinct container sets.containers[totalNumContainers][2]: A 2D array describing all container sizes across all sets. Each inner arraycontainers[k]contains:containers[k][0]: The set index (an integer from0tonumContainerSets - 1).containers[k][1]: A container capacity (a positive integer) belonging to that set.
Additional Guarantees for containers:
- Rows are grouped by set index in increasing order.
- Within each set, its capacities are listed in non-decreasing order.
Constraints:
You may assume reasonable constraints such as:
1 ≤ n ≤ 10^51 ≤ numContainerSets ≤ 10^51 ≤ totalNumContainers ≤ 10^51 ≤ requirements[i] ≤ 10^91 ≤ containers[k][1] ≤ 10^9
Waste Calculation for a Single Set
For a specific container set s with capacities C_s and an order of size r:
- Let
cbe the smallest capacity inC_ssuch thatc ≥ r. - The waste for this order under set
sisc - r. - If no such
cexists (i.e., all capacities inC_sare< r), then setsis invalid and cannot be used.
The total waste for set s is the sum of wastes over all orders in requirements.
Required Function
Implement the following function:
int chooseContainers(int requirements[n],
int numContainerSets,
int containers[totalNumContainers][2])
Return Value:
- The 0-based index of the container set that yields the minimum total waste while satisfying all requirements. If multiple such sets exist, return the smallest index among them.
- If no container set can satisfy all requirements, return
-1.
Your algorithm must be efficient enough to handle inputs up to 10^5 in size; a naive solution with O(n × totalNumContainers) time complexity or worse will time out.
Example
n = 4
requirements = [4, 6, 6, 7]
numContainerSets = 3
containers = [
[0, 3], [0, 5], [0, 7], // set 0: capacities {3, 5, 7}
[1, 6], [1, 8], [1, 9], // set 1: capacities {6, 8, 9}
[2, 3], [2, 5], [2, 6] // set 2: capacities {3, 5, 6}
]
- Set 0 with capacities
{3, 5, 7}:- Requirement 4 → use capacity 5 → waste = 5 − 4 = 1
- Requirement 6 → use capacity 7 → waste = 7 − 6 = 1
- Requirement 6 → use capacity 7 → waste = 1
- Requirement 7 → use capacity 7 → waste = 0
- Total waste for set 0:
1 + 1 + 1 + 0 = 3.
- Set 1 with capacities
{6, 8, 9}:- Requirement 4 → use capacity 6 → waste = 6 − 4 = 2
- Requirement 6 → use capacity 6 → waste = 0
- Requirement 6 → use capacity 6 → waste = 0
- Requirement 7 → use capacity 8 → waste = 8 − 7 = 1
- Total waste for set 1:
2 + 0 + 0 + 1 = 3.
- Set 2 with capacities
{3, 5, 6}:- Cannot satisfy requirement 7, as its maximum capacity is 6 < 7.
- Therefore, set 2 is invalid.
Both set 0 and set 1 are valid and yield a total waste of 3. As the smallest index is required, the correct answer is 0.